Attitudes toward abortion

Leslie Cannold, a prominent Australian abortion advocate has stated in an ABC radio interview that a small minority of only 4-9% of Australians believe abortion should not be available.   I often hear these kinds of figures, yet have found little to substantiate them.  After some thorough googling, placing an emphasis on research undertaken by abortion advocacy groups, I found the following.

The Australian Reproductive Health Alliance (ARHA), in 2004 state the less than 5% of the Australian population oppose abortion under any circumstances and go on to quote the Public Health Association as saying, "It is overwhelmingly clear that the majority of Australians support liberal access to abortion". 

Interestingly, ARHA later state that only just over 80% of Australians are 'prochoice', identifying 13.8% of Australians as disagreeing or strongly disagreeing that abortion should be available.   The remaining 7.3% either responded 'don't know' or didn't respond at all.

This report also shows that only 54.2% of people agree that abortion should be 'readily available when they want one', as opposed to 34.5% who believe abortion should be allowed 'only in special circumstances', however these circumstances are not detailed.

A later study in 2008, undertaken by Lachlan de Crespigny and associates asks a variety of questions addressing very specific circumstances of women.  This study indicates that only 61% of Australians agree that that abortion should be legal, without condition in the first trimester, with a further 26% believing restrictions should be in place according to circumstances.   By the third trimester the number of people believing abortion should be available without restriction drops to a low 6% with a further 42% agreeing about availability dependent on circumstances.    The percentage of people believing abortion should be illegal regardless of circumstances increase with each trimester, 12%, 28% and 48%.

Further information about the kinds of circumstances that are important to people's beliefs become apparent when people are asked whether doctors should face professional sanctions for performing abortions after 24 weeks gestation.  Whilst the discussion states that the majority of respondents do not support sanctions against doctors, the numbers who do are highly significant and do not support the idea that the publicly are generally accepting of abortion.

With a minimum of 11% of respondents believing doctors should face sanctions for post 24 week abortions and 11% responding 'can't say'  and up to 45% wanting sanctions and 28% responding 'can't say' for reasons of psychosocial concerns, there does not appear to be the widespread support for abortion that abortion advocates claim, particularly as pregnancy progresses.

With significantly less than half of all respondents believing abortion should be lawful after 24 weeks for reasons of abuse, economics, economics or other social reasons, and from 23-28% declining to answer, one wonders how legislation making abortion legal until birth, for any reason actually came about.

It seems that even when looking  at the research conducted by abortion advocates, and abortion advocacy organisations,  the stated support for abortion is wildly exaggerated, with significant numbers of people expressing a desire for abortion to not be available at all for many circumstances, particularly in later gestations.   The percentage of people stating that they are unable to respond suggests some ambivalence about, or perhaps not enough knowledge about abortion for significant numbers as well.

The reason this is important is that many people who express concern about abortion and the circumstances that lead women to consider abortion, are often silenced and stigmatised as being 'out of step' with public opinion and misogynistic.   The fact is that those who question are actually in the majority, but are often too afraid to speak.  Questioning the social failings toward women in challenging circumstances during pregnancy is not a sign of hating women.  To the contrary, it expresses a much deeper compassion to women than forcing her to make a decision she may not be happy or comfortable with, labeling it her 'choice' and then expecting her to only speak positively about it later.    

 

 

 

Written by

2 Comments to “Attitudes toward abortion”

  1. Alex says:

    I am sad to see that you simultaneously state that your website is aimed at helping people make informed choices given all the information, then blatantly promotes anti abortion, you can’t have it both ways and you certainly give no attempt at unbiased information. Then again, this kind of thinly veiled message will only seek to highlight exactly what your organisation is.

    • Debbie Garratt says:

      Hi Alex, Thanks for your comment. It would be great if you could be more specific about what you object to in our information. We provide a lot of general information about abortion and unintended pregnancy, as well as particular information about the mental health impact of abortion, as stated in our About Us page. The information is accurate and well referenced.

      It is important that women, and men have access to all the information they require to fully inform their decision making processes. Information about the adverse impact of abortion is difficult for many to obtain, despite the growing evidence base that a substantial number of women can suffer seriously following abortion. Our aim is not to promote an ideology, but to listen to the stories of women, about what they wish they’d known, and then seek to provide that information for others.

      Please let us know if you have found inaccuracies, or anything confusing and I’d be more than happy to have a look at it and either clarify for you, or update if needed. Thanks again for taking the time to visit us. Debbie

  2. […] a study undertaken by practitioners in abortion reveals a very different set of community values when people are […]

  3. […] of the public support such a step, yet none of the research supports this. In fact, according to abortion advocate’s own research, only 6% believe abortion should be available for any reason in the third […]

Leave a Reply

Message